Let me begin by defining what grades mean to me. Grades are my way of monitoring my progress. I don’t look at grades as the end all be all of education, never have. I look to grades to tell me that I am learning. Learning as much as I should be; learning as much as I can be. A’s are nice, A+ are better. Maybe it comes from being in private education my whole life, the thought that I (rather my parents) are legitimately paying for my education and I should make the most of it. Maybe part of it comes from my strengths (Learner Input and Intellection have a lot to do with education). I don’t think there is one cause for it, but regardless, grades are how I know I am comprehending, retaining, accomplishing as much as I can. 98% means I missed 2% of learning, a chance for improvement.
I am a fairly self-motivated person, so grades serve mostly a monitoring purpose for me. I can’t speak authoritatively for others, but I do know people who are in it for the grade. I know bright serious students, and dull lazy ones who appear to be in it for the mark on their transcript.
I would not say that Phaedrus is right here. The vast majority of bright students enjoy grades as benchmarks for themselves. They, like me as far as I can tell, use grades to quantify their learning, make sure they are doing right and doing well. Grades are not the end all be all, most quality students recognize that, but most quality students still like A’s.
I think it goes hand and hand with quality. Phaedrus still graded his students in the end, and I think mentally the students were giving themselves grades all along. They help quantify progress, give another indicator of quality, one outside ourselves, which is important because I believe quality is not determined by a single person more than it is by a single component of the piece.
Heck, even labeling something quality is giving a grade!
No comments:
Post a Comment