Banking education is like the penguin documentaries on the Discovery Channel. Experienced penguins travel to the sea, load up on fish, and then vomit in the mouths of the youth. Similarly, teachers travel through the world, obtain knowledge and their impression of the world, and then vomit in their students’ ears. This might work for baby penguins, defenseless as they are, but could you imagine an adult penguin vomiting in another adult’s mouth, one who had tasted fish first-hand? That penguin would be revolted. Similarly, if teachers deny their students’ previous interaction with and current involvement in the world, that they are creatures capable of individual, human experience, students receive an education that is revolting.
Keeping with the penguin analogy for continuity’s sake, if penguins in the process of becoming independent are taken alongside those who have experienced the world and are allowed to interact with world at hand (what Freire labels the cognizable object) the penguin gains greater benefit. Perhaps even the older penguin learns a few new tricks as they dodge sea lions and explore still deeper waters (I trust your interpretation of this part of the analogy to be accurate).
I have had teachers vomit into my brain before, and I have had teachers explore the depths of the sea with me as a companion as well. Let’s examine one department in particular: English. Analysis is a key component to studying literature, but if all a teacher expects you to give him is the fish carcass he forced down your throat yesterday, then no real-world interaction or learning process occurs. A sophomore year spent regurgitating a ten-page paper on a single person’s perspective of The Red Badge of Courage, for example, would be of little use to teacher, student, or greater literary community (I speak from experience). But analysis is fostered in such a way as my junior English teacher did: encouraging thematic exploration, self-interpretation of literary devices, and a critical, multifaceted view of, say, Peace Like a River by Leif Enger, then both student, teacher, and greater community reap the benefits of fresh insight and an additional perspective (new fish if you will).
My belly (brain) grew fatter on the fish I caught alongside my junior English teacher than on the copious amounts of vomit I received from the year prior: and you can take that to the bank (pun intended).